Today’s Teacher: Buddha (563 – 483 BCE)
The Teaching
“Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.”
— Buddha
Who Was Buddha?
Siddhartha Gautama, who became known as the Buddha (meaning “the awakened one”), was born into royalty in what is now Nepal. His father, a king, was told by prophets that his son would either become a great ruler or a great spiritual teacher. Desperate to ensure the former, his father surrounded young Siddhartha with luxury and carefully shielded him from any sight of suffering.
For 29 years, Siddhartha lived in palaces, surrounded by beauty, pleasure, and carefully curated perfection. He had wealth, a beautiful wife, a newborn son, and every comfort imaginable. By all external measures, he had everything.
Then one day, he ventured outside the palace walls. What he saw changed everything: an old man, a sick person, a corpse, and finally, a wandering ascetic monk. These “Four Sights” shattered his illusion. He realized that no matter how much luxury his father provided, everyone faces aging, sickness, and death. No one escapes suffering.
That night, he left everything—his kingdom, his wife, his infant son, his wealth—and set out to find the answer to one question: Is there a way to end suffering?
For six years, he practiced extreme asceticism, nearly starving himself to death. That didn’t work. Finally, sitting under a bodhi tree, he vowed not to rise until he understood the nature of suffering. After 49 days of meditation, he achieved enlightenment. He saw the truth clearly.
For the next 45 years, Buddha taught what he discovered: while pain is inevitable in life, the suffering we experience on top of that pain is created by our own minds—and therefore, it’s optional.
Understanding the Wisdom
Pain vs. Suffering: The Crucial Distinction
Most people use these words interchangeably. Buddha says they’re completely different:
Pain is inevitable:
- Your body will age
- You will experience physical injury and illness
- People you love will die
- Relationships will end
- You will lose things you care about
- Plans will fail
- Life will disappoint you
- You will eventually die
This is reality. This is being human. Pain is part of life.
Suffering is optional: Suffering is what your mind adds to pain:
- Resisting reality (“This shouldn’t be happening!”)
- Ruminating on the past (“Why did this happen to me?”)
- Catastrophizing the future (“Now everything is ruined forever!”)
- Taking things personally (“I’m being punished/targeted”)
- Creating stories about the pain (“This means I’m worthless”)
- Attaching to outcomes (“It must be exactly as I want or I can’t be happy”)
Example – You stub your toe:
Pain: Sharp physical sensation for about 30 seconds. Inevitable. Real.
Suffering (optional additions):
- “Why does this always happen to me?!” (Story)
- Hobbling around furious for 20 minutes (Resistance)
- “This ruined my whole morning!” (Catastrophizing)
- “I’m such an idiot!” (Self-judgment)
- Telling everyone about it all day (Attachment to the narrative)
The stub lasted 30 seconds. The suffering lasted all day. The pain was inevitable. The suffering was created by your mind—and therefore, optional.
The Second Arrow
Buddha taught about “the second arrow”:
First arrow: Life shoots you with pain. Someone criticizes you. You get sick. You fail at something. This arrow is inevitable.
Second arrow: You shoot yourself with suffering. You ruminate on the criticism. You spiral into anxiety about illness. You create a whole story about being a failure.
Most of our suffering comes not from the first arrow, but from the second one—the one we shoot at ourselves.
Buddha isn’t saying “Don’t feel pain” (that’s impossible and unhealthy). He’s saying “Don’t add unnecessary suffering on top of inevitable pain.”
How to Practice This Wisdom Today
1. Morning Pain-Suffering Distinction (5 minutes)
Start your day by learning to distinguish between pain and suffering.
Reflect on a recent difficult experience:
Ask yourself:
- What was the inevitable pain? (The actual facts of what happened)
- What suffering did I add? (The stories, resistance, rumination)
- Was that added suffering necessary or helpful? (Honest assessment)
Example:
Situation: Friend cancelled plans last minute
Inevitable pain: Disappointment (natural, brief emotional response)
Added suffering:
- “They don’t really care about me” (Story – not necessarily true)
- “I’m always everyone’s second choice” (Pattern – not based on reality)
- Spent entire evening ruminating on past cancellations (Unnecessary mental torture)
- Posted passive-aggressive social media status (Creating more drama)
Was the suffering necessary? No. I could have felt disappointed for 10 minutes and moved on. Instead, I turned a minor disappointment into an evening of misery.
Today’s practice: When pain arises, notice it, feel it, then choose not to add suffering.
2. The First Arrow Recognition Practice (Throughout the Day)
When something difficult happens today, practice recognizing the arrows:
The Event Happens:
PAUSE.
Ask:
- “What’s the first arrow?” (The inevitable pain – what actually happened)
- “Am I reaching for the second arrow?” (Notice the mind starting to create stories)
- “Can I feel this pain without adding suffering?” (Experience pain without resistance)
Example – Stuck in traffic:
First arrow (pain): Traffic delay. You’re going to be late. This is frustrating. (Inevitable)
Second arrow (suffering) – Notice these thoughts arising:
- “This is the worst! This always happens!”
- “Everyone at the meeting will think I’m irresponsible”
- “My whole day is ruined”
- “Why is traffic so terrible in this city?!”
- Gripping steering wheel, tensing body, raising blood pressure
Practice:
- Acknowledge: “I’m stuck in traffic. I’ll be late. That’s frustrating.” (First arrow – feel it)
- Choose: “I don’t need to add stories to this. It’s just traffic.” (Put down second arrow)
- Accept: “This is the current reality. Getting angry doesn’t change it.” (Stop resisting)
- Breathe: Relax body, release tension (Don’t create physical suffering)
You’re still stuck in traffic. But you’re not suffering about being stuck in traffic.
3. The Resistance Check (Midday Practice)
Buddha taught that resistance to reality is a primary source of suffering.
Midday, check where you’re resisting reality:
Ask: “Where am I arguing with reality today?”
Common resistances:
- “This shouldn’t have happened”
- “They shouldn’t be this way”
- “Life should be fair”
- “I should be further along by now”
- “This must change immediately or I can’t be okay”
When you spot resistance:
Remember: Reality doesn’t care about your “shoulds.” It just is.
Practice acceptance: “This IS happening. Resistance doesn’t change it—it just adds suffering.”
Redirect energy: Stop arguing with reality. Use that energy to respond skillfully instead.
Example – Rain ruined outdoor plans:
Resistance (suffering): “This shouldn’t be raining! The forecast said sunny! My plans are ruined! This is terrible!”
Acceptance (no added suffering): “It’s raining. My outdoor plans won’t work. That’s disappointing. What can I do instead?”
Same rain. One person suffers for hours. The other adapts in minutes.
4. Evening Suffering Inventory (10 minutes)
Before bed, examine the suffering you created today:
Write brief answers:
- What pain did I experience today? (Inevitable life challenges)
- What suffering did I add to that pain? (Stories, resistance, rumination)
- How much time did I spend in added suffering vs. actual pain?
- Pain usually lasts minutes
- Suffering can last hours or days if you let it
- What would today have felt like without the added suffering?
- Tomorrow, when pain arises, I will practice ___________.
The goal: Gradually train yourself to experience pain without automatically adding layers of suffering.
A Modern Application: The Difficult Diagnosis
Let’s apply this to something genuinely painful: receiving a difficult medical diagnosis.
The inevitable pain (first arrow):
- You have a health condition
- It will require treatment
- Your life will change in some ways
- There’s uncertainty about outcomes
- This is scary and sad
- You feel grief, fear, anger (all natural, valid emotions)
This pain is real and legitimate. Feel it. Honor it. Don’t minimize it.
The optional suffering (second arrows you might shoot yourself with):
Catastrophizing:
- “This means my life is over”
- “Everything good is now impossible”
- “I’ll definitely die soon”
Victimhood stories:
- “Why me? This is so unfair!”
- “I did everything right and still got sick”
- “God/universe is punishing me”
Comparison torture:
- “Everyone else gets to be healthy”
- “I’ll never have the life others have”
- Scrolling social media, envying healthy people
Future projection:
- Living as if the worst-case scenario is guaranteed
- Mourning futures that haven’t happened yet
- “I can’t be happy until I’m cured”
Identity fusion:
- “I am my disease”
- Entire personality becomes “sick person”
- Lose all other dimensions of self
The difference this makes:
Person A (pain + suffering): Receives diagnosis → spends months in mental agony, worst-case catastrophizing, withdrawing from life, becoming bitter, letting the disease define them entirely. Result: The disease affects their body AND destroys their mental peace, relationships, and remaining quality of life.
Person B (pain, minimal added suffering): Receives diagnosis → feels the grief and fear deeply for a period → accepts the reality → asks “What now?” → focuses on what they CAN control (treatment, lifestyle, attitude) → continues living meaningfully within new constraints → connects with others facing similar challenges → refuses to let the diagnosis become their entire identity. Result: The disease affects their body, but their mind remains relatively free. They suffer less despite identical circumstances.
Same diagnosis. Same pain. Vastly different suffering.
Buddha isn’t saying Person B isn’t hurting. He’s saying Person B isn’t adding unnecessary torture to inevitable pain.
The Deeper Philosophy
The Four Noble Truths
Buddha’s entire teaching rests on Four Noble Truths:
1. Suffering exists (Dukkha) Life includes pain, dissatisfaction, and impermanence. This isn’t pessimism—it’s realism.
2. Suffering has a cause (Samudaya) Suffering comes from attachment, aversion, and ignorance. We cling to what we want and resist what we don’t want. We don’t see reality clearly.
3. Suffering can end (Nirodha) Because suffering is created by the mind, the mind can also release it. This is liberation.
4. There’s a path to end suffering (Magga) The Eightfold Path: right understanding, intention, speech, action, livelihood, effort, mindfulness, concentration.
The core insight: Pain is unavoidable. Suffering is created by how we relate to pain—and we can learn to relate differently.
Attachment and Aversion
Buddha taught that suffering comes primarily from two movements:
Attachment (clinging): “I must have this to be happy. If I lose this, I can’t be okay.”
- Attachment to people, possessions, status, youth, health, plans
- When these change or disappear (which they will—everything is impermanent), you suffer
Aversion (resistance): “I can’t tolerate this. This must not be happening.”
- Resistance to pain, aging, loss, change, failure, discomfort
- Life includes these things; resisting them guarantees suffering
The middle way:
- Enjoy things without clinging to them
- Work to change what you can, accept what you cannot
- Hold your preferences lightly
- Remember: everything changes, nothing lasts
This doesn’t mean not caring. It means caring without attachment—loving without clinging, engaging without demanding permanence.
The Freedom of Non-Attachment
People misunderstand non-attachment as not caring. Buddha meant something different:
Attachment says: “I love you AND I need you to be exactly as I want forever or I can’t be okay.”
Non-attached love says: “I love you deeply AND I know you will change and eventually die, as will I. I cherish this moment without demanding it last forever.”
Attachment suffers constantly:
- When present: “What if I lose this?”
- When absent: “I need this back!”
- When changing: “No! Stay the same!”
Non-attachment experiences more peace:
- When present: Full presence and appreciation
- When absent: Grief without desperation
- When changing: Acceptance of life’s nature
Paradoxically, non-attachment allows for deeper love—because you’re not gripping so tightly you strangle what you love.
Your Practice for Today
Here’s your challenge based on Buddha’s teaching:
Today, practice experiencing pain without adding suffering.
The Practice:
1. When pain arises (and it will):
Physical pain: Stubbed toe, headache, sore muscles Emotional pain: Disappointment, frustration, sadness Social pain: Criticism, rejection, conflict Existential pain: Uncertainty, loss, change
2. Practice the RAIN method:
R – Recognize: “I’m experiencing pain right now.”
A – Allow: Don’t resist it. Let the pain be present without fighting it.
I – Investigate: “What’s the actual pain vs. what stories am I adding?”
N – Non-identification: “I’m experiencing this, but I am not this. It will pass.”
3. Notice suffering-creating thoughts and let them go:
When your mind reaches for the second arrow:
- “This is terrible!” → Notice, don’t engage
- “Why me?” → Notice, don’t engage
- “This ruins everything!” → Notice, don’t engage
- “I can’t handle this!” → Notice, don’t engage
Like clouds passing through the sky—notice them, don’t chase them.
4. At day’s end, assess:
- How much of today’s difficulty was inevitable pain?
- How much was optional suffering I created?
- When did I successfully experience pain without adding suffering?
- What did that feel like?
Start small. You won’t eliminate all suffering today. But can you reduce it by 10%? Can you catch yourself reaching for one second arrow and choose not to pick it up?
That’s the practice. That’s the path.
Essential Reading: Dive Deeper into Buddha
If this teaching resonates with you, explore these books:
Primary Sources:
- Collection of Buddha’s sayings
- Short, poetic verses
- Accessible entry point to Buddhist wisdom
- Multiple translations available
In the Buddha’s Words edited by Bhikkhu Bodhi
- Carefully selected teachings from original texts
- Organized by theme
- Scholarly but accessible
- Excellent for understanding core teachings
Modern Interpretations:
When Things Fall Apart by Pema Chödrön
- Buddhist wisdom for difficult times
- Practical, compassionate, profound
- Modern American nun’s accessible teachings
- Perfect for those suffering now
The Heart of the Buddha’s Teaching by Thich Nhat Hanh
- Clear explanation of core Buddhist concepts
- From one of the most beloved Buddhist teachers
- Bridges ancient wisdom and modern life
- Warm, accessible, practical
Applied Wisdom:
Radical Acceptance by Tara Brach
- Buddhist psychology meets Western therapy
- Practical exercises for accepting pain without suffering
- Deeply compassionate approach
- Modern application of ancient wisdom
The Mindful Way Through Depression by Mark Williams et al.
- Science-backed mindfulness approach
- Based on Buddhist principles
- Clinical applications proven effective
- Includes guided meditation CD
- Skeptical journalist discovers meditation
- Buddhism for people who don’t like “woo-woo”
- Practical, funny, honest
- Great gateway book
Closing Reflection
Buddha left a palace—everything most people chase their entire lives—because he saw through the illusion. Comfort and luxury couldn’t protect him from aging, sickness, and death. Pleasure couldn’t prevent pain.
So he went seeking the truth about suffering. And what he discovered 2,500 years ago remains as true today:
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
Today, you will experience pain:
- Things won’t go as planned
- Someone will disappoint you
- Your body will ache
- Something you care about will change
- Life will be imperfect
This is the first arrow. It’s inevitable.
But you will also be tempted to pick up the second arrow:
- To resist reality
- To create stories about what this means
- To catastrophize the future
- To make it worse than it needs to be
This is optional. You can put down the second arrow.
The pain will still hurt. But you won’t compound it with unnecessary suffering. You’ll experience it, honor it, let it move through you—without letting it destroy your peace.
This is the path Buddha taught. This is liberation.
Not from pain—that’s impossible while alive.
But from the suffering we add to pain—that’s entirely within your control.
Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.
What will you choose today?
Reflection Questions
Take a moment to journal or contemplate:
- Where am I currently shooting myself with second arrows—creating suffering beyond inevitable pain?
- What reality am I resisting instead of accepting?
- What am I clinging to so tightly that the inevitable loss or change will devastate me?
- How would my life feel if I experienced pain without adding layers of suffering?
Tomorrow’s Wisdom
Join us tomorrow as we explore a teaching from Frederick Douglass, abolitionist and former slave, on the relationship between power and struggle, and why freedom must be claimed, never merely requested.
Want daily wisdom delivered to your inbox? Subscribe below to receive timeless teachings from history’s greatest minds, made practical for modern life.
Essential Reading: 📚 The Dhammapada – Buddha’s core sayings 📖 When Things Fall Apart – Buddhist wisdom for difficult times
🎯 The Heart of the Buddha’s Teaching – Clear, comprehensive guide 💫 Radical Acceptance – Accept pain, release suffering
Leave a Reply